I love this particular time of year, but I especially enjoy Thanksgiving. There’s no gift buying pressure, just plenty of good food and fun times to share with family and friends. While I realize it’s only the 1st of November, you and I both know the time will fly and before you know it you’ll be making your grocery list for the feast.
I enjoy cooking but I probably enjoying eating as much. Alison over at The Polohouse is hosting her Favorites On the First and the topic is your favorite Thanksgiving recipe. At first I was perplexed…should I feature a mouth-watering pumpkin pie recipe or the Texas Stuffing I found in the Los Angeles Times Food Section years ago?
When it comes right down to it though, I think my favorite thing for the meal is mashed potatoes. We don’t eat them that often and we certainly don’t throw on gravy for good measure when we do. As if creamy, buttery potatoes need something more! But Thanksgiving we throw waistline watching out the window and gravy tops every helping of mashed potatoes. Anyway, my favorite recipe is called make-ahead mashed potatoes (which is one of the things I like best about the recipe.) Here goes:
{image source and another delicious potato recipe}
Make Ahead Mashed Potatoes ~ adapted from HERE
Oven, preheated 350° at the time you’re planning on reheating the potatoes.
5 pounds potatoes, Russet or Yukon Gold
1 1/2 sticks of butter, divided
1 8 oz whipped cream cheese
1/2 cup Half & Half
2 teaspoon kosher salt [1 teaspoon in the pot while the potatoes boil, 1 teaspoon (or less, depending on taste preference) when mashing]
1/2 teaspoon freshly ground pepper
Peel and cut the potatoes. Bring a large pot of water to a boil, add 1 teaspoon salt, add potatoes and return the water to a boil. Cook for 30 minutes and check for tenderness. Once the potatoes are cooked, drain in a colander. Return the potatoes to the pot and turn the stove on low, just to make sure all of the moisture is gone.
Off the flame, add 1 stick of butter, remaining salt, pepper, half & half, and cream cheese. Mash to a creamy consistency. *Don’t worry if they seem a little bit soupy, they firm up when refrigerated. Once mashed, place in an oven-proof dish and dot with the remaining 1/2 stick of butter. Potatoes may be refrigerated at this point. If you make the recipe a couple days in advance, take the dish out of the fridge about 2 hours before serving time. Bake uncovered in a 350 degree oven for about 20-30 minutes or until hot.
By the way, the above image reminds me of the first Martha Stewart Thanksgiving special on TV. She had converted her “barn” into the most warm and welcoming dining space, as only she can do!
How cute are these pudding cups? If you have children or just like delicious food visit HERE
Do you have a personal favorite recipe for Thanksgiving? If its not a family secret, share. If you have time be sure to visit The Polohouse, you’re sure to be happy you did.
Lisa said:
I looove mashed potatoes. I can’t tell you about Thanksgiving because we don’t celebrate that in my country. 🙂
Karen B. said:
Lisa,
It’s nice to meet another mashed potato enthusiast. I’d say there’s always reason to have mashed potatoes, no matter what the celebration. 😀
Karen
Victoria • Restoring our Victorian said:
I like mashed potatoes too… But hands-down the best holiday dish is my mom’s stuffing. I would tell you how to make it, but I have no idea.
That is at least half of what makes it so delicious – not having to do any work.
PS – I love that last photo with the painted pumpkins.
Karen B. said:
Yes, I’ve given the cooking baton over to our local DIL, although I still have to cook a few things, it’s way easier than preparing the entire T-day meal. You must ask mom for the recipe, I promise I won’t publish it or anything. I’m always search for a wonderful stuffing recipe. 😀
Lyn Bunch (@analogsherpa) said:
…more butter in the potatoes please !
Karen B. said:
Hey, we only eat them once or twenty times a year!
xo,
Karen
Linda Coble said:
Karen,
These potatoes look positively sinful! Thanksgiving is one of my favorite holidays too, for all the reasons you mentioned. I look forward to it every year and the pics you featured have given me some ideas for my table this year. Leave it to Martha Stewart to decorate a “barn” like it’s a Fall wonderland!
Karen B. said:
The potatoes are delicious, decadent, but delicious. xo, Karen
Kelly - Talk of the House said:
Your images in this post are beyond gorgeous! I loved loved that dog place setting…until I read how expensive they were. Gosh, I was planning to look for some. And your mashed potato recipe sounds like one my whole crew would devour. I will have to try that one soon…with meatloaf! I especially like that it can be made ahead. Perfect! My favorite dish for Thanksgiving is my husband’s aunt’s homemade caramel cake. The icing is to die for! (And we fight for the corner piece!)
Karen B. said:
Kelly, Maybe your husband’s aunt will let you share that recipe…our family loves caramel anything. Yes, the potatoes are good but truly, one of the favorite things about the recipe is it works perfectly at Thanksgiving when the oven is at capacity. I guess if you add enough fat to any thing it reheats well. 😀 Have a wonderful weekend. Karen
D'Arcy H said:
Thanksgiving dinner is my favorite meal to cook AND eat (and eat and eat)! Even though it’s just Eric and me at our house, I do the whole traditional spread. My favorite recipe is my stuffing, which has craizins, dried apricots, and currents in it. I got it from a Glamour magazine back in the 80s and have used it every year because it’s so scrumptious.
I just love some of the decorating ideas in your post … I like the rustic + elegant look. Makes me wish I were cooking for a crowd! Thanks for getting me thinking about the big meal! 🙂
Karen B. said:
D’Arcy, I have never been a huge fan of stuffing but I believe it’s because I’ve just not met the right one. On my visit to Austin last week, my DIL’s mom and I went to lunch and she ordered a stuffing that was so delicious…it was a little spicy but very good. I’m now on a quest to find a similar recipe. I do love crasins and might really enjoy one with a little sweetness. What a blast from the past…Glamour used to be my favorite magazine in my youth. When Mr. B and I have not had a ton of family (we’re only children) for T-day, I still cook the whole feast too. xo, Karen
Debbie@Mountain Breaths said:
I host Thanksgiving dinner every year, and I do look forward to the mashed potatoes. I am always asked to make two kinds, one of which is bacon cheddar mashed. The image that reminds you of Martha Stewart’s converted barn would be perfect for our 16 family members that join us.
Karen B. said:
Debbie, Oh my, that recipe for bacon cheddar mashed potatoes has to be delicious. I hosted for all of our kids growing up years…one married son lives in Austin and we don’t usually see him for Thanksgiving, just Christmas, but our younger married son lives locally and they have taken over the traditon, I still bring a couple of dishes for the feast. I do love this holiday. So nice to meet you, thanks for stopping by. Karen
Alison said:
What a gorgeous post with such lovely images, Karen!
I love a good old heap of mashed potatoes too and a few years ago
my mother in law started making the day ahead potatoes and I think they
taste even better that way! The flavors have a chance to mingle and the
result is always heavenly!
And honestly, if I can make one or two things the day before the big feast — i can enjoy Thanksgiving Day that much more!
Thanks for sharing your recipe. I need to pull mine out and see if they the same!
xoxoxox
Alison
Karen B. said:
Alison, I’m counting the days until the big feast. I plan to make your sweet potato recipe to add to the mix. xo, Karen
Gretchen said:
I am fortunate enough to have tried your mashed potatoes – fabulous! It’s just not Thanksgiving if the mashed potatoes aren’t great.
My favorite dish at the Thanksgivings of my childhood was my mom’s cornbread stuffing. She baked the cornbread first thing on Thanksgiving morning and I remember waking up to that wonderful aroma.
I would love to have an invitation to Thanksgiving in that barn, wouldn’t you?
Karen B. said:
Yes, that barn is fabulous. I will always remember the Martha Stewart barn on her first Thanksgiving television show. Xo, Karen
Sent from my iPad
>
DS sha-Bra said:
These are the best ideas I have viewed on any site. There is an excellent choice for anyone. FROM decorating to recipes.